Shiloh 1862 contest!!! Forrest Gump author’s new ACW book!

I recently received a copy of Winston Groom’s latest book, Shiloh 1862. Groom has utilized new sources to weave a highly readable account of the bloody battle fought 150 years ago this spring.

The publisher will give away 3 free books to Charge! readers. Here’s what you can do to earn a free book. Simply comment (below) on what you believe the best and worst generalship was in the battle. Who did well; who did poorly? What decisions were lame (or brilliant). I will randomly select the three winners from all of the comments left on this blog entry within 1 week.

And now, here is some more information on Shiloh 1862

WASHINGTON (Feb., 2012)—The Civil War saw some of the most bitter battles fought by American soldiers. According to Winston Groom, distinguished Civil War historian and author of the best-selling “Forrest Gump,” one battle set the stage for those to come. In his new book SHILOH, 1862 (National Geographic Books; ISBN 978-1-4262-0874-4; on-sale date: March 20, 2012; $30 hardcover), Groom gives a masterful account of the Battle of Shiloh, fought by 100,000 soldiers in the wilderness of southern Tennessee, which marked a violent crossroads in the Civil War.

The Battle of Shiloh began on April 6, 1862, when Confederate troops led by Albert Sidney Johnston launched a bold, surprise attack on a Union stronghold under the leadership of Gen. Ulysses S. Grant to gain control of the Mississippi River Valley. With improved weaponry, a decades-long buildup of hatred, and many untrained soldiers who had never fought in war before, the battle turned into a shocking tragedy for both sides. “It was so bloody and destructive that in many cases soldiers writing home could simply not find words to describe it,” writes Groom. In a single day, more casualties resulted in Shiloh than all previous wars combined, including the American Revolution. After two days of combat, Grant was able to bring his Union troops to a victory, but nearly 24,000 soldiers had lost their lives, and the American people knew the war they thought was ending was only beginning.

In SHILOH, 1862 Groom deftly crafts a dramatic narrative of the battle from beginning to end. Key characters are highlighted as he places their personal history in the context of the battle. Stories are woven together from a number of memoirs and diaries, including 9-year-old Elsie Duncan’s, whose home became a safe house for soldiers. Personal accounts from famed journalist Henry Morton Stanley and author Ambrose Bierce are also included, providing a thorough look at the battle through a variety of perspectives.

Groom’s ability to bring context and meaning to this important battle 150 years later is evident throughout the book. Each epic moment is thoroughly detailed, giving readers an in-depth look into two days of chaos, disorder and bloodletting. Historian Otto Eisenschiml, an early chronicler of the battle, said even though “Gettysburg was bigger; Vicksburg was more decisive, Antietam even more bloody,” Shiloh was “the most dramatic battle fought on American soil.”

“For those who endured it, Shiloh was more than a dream; it was a living nightmare that no one could forget. The sheer magnitude of the butchery staggered the imagination. In one sense, the battle had settled nothing except to keep the coffin makers busy,” writes Groom. “But the significance of Shiloh was not so much that the Rebel army failed to subdue Grant, or that Grant resisted it, than it was to impress on the nation — both nations — that there was never going to be some neat and exquisite military maneuver that would end the war — or even come close to ending the war.”
With its comprehensive maps, photographs and epic storytelling that highlights the major personalities, politics and mind-set of the day, SHILOH, 1862 is a compelling look at a battle that changed the course of the Civil War and American history.

About the Author

Winston Groom is the author of 15 previous books, including “Vicksburg, 1863”; “Forrest Gump”; which is now celebrating its 25th anniversary; and (with Duncan Spencer) “Conversations with the Enemy,” a Pulitzer Prize finalist. In 2011, Groom received the Harper Lee Award for Alabama’s Distinguished Writer of the Year. A graduate of the University of Alabama, he lives in Point Clear, Ala., with his wife and daughter.


For more information on Shiloh 1862:—1862

Categories: Civil War books | Tags: | 6 Comments

Post navigation

6 thoughts on “Shiloh 1862 contest!!! Forrest Gump author’s new ACW book!

  1. Gen Johnston and his staff did an excellent job of essentially marching their army undetected to Shiloh and achieving strategic surprise. Grant wasn’t in the vicinity of the battle when it started and he and Sherman did not have the USA army ready for defense. These were mistakes they would learn from and not repeat. The CSA deployment was bad in that they should have had the corps deployed in depth, not across and broad linear front. They would have had better command and control and better use of self-supporting reserves so deployed. They could have hit harder on day one and sustained the attack and/or had a better defense on day two.

  2. Scott, Gen. Johnston and his staff did an excellent job marching their men essentially undetected to Shiloh. On the other hand, Grant and Sherman did a horrible job of scouting the enemy and deploying their men in a more defensible position. Polk, Bragg and Hardee’s corps should have been deployed in depth, not linear across a broad front. This would have allowed for better command and control and use of reserves and likely a bigger push on day one and/or a better defensive position on day two to meet the Union counterattack. Buell and his men did a good job of raising USA morale and turning the tide on day two. Grant and Sherman got lucky, but at least they learned from their mistakes. Cory

  3. Worst – General Sherman consistently ignoring warnings of the confederate approach. Best – General Sherman managing to hold on despite his earlier failure

  4. Worst is probably the Confederate deployment, which must have made command and control pretty difficult and confused. Best, I’ll give to General Johnston personally leading an assault on a position near a peach orchard that had repelled many previous attacks. Sure, he got himself killed, which was a blow to the confederacy, but if you’re going to get killed, that’s the way to do it.

  5. George Krashos

    The bets bit of generalship was the decision of Brig General Ruggles to form his grand battery and pound the Hornet’s Nest, paving the way for a renewed assault that broke the Union position. Given the unimaginative frontal assaults that preceded it, it was the decisive act of the first day.

  6. Worst – General Robert E. Lee at Gettysburg. He sought a decisive battle and got it and lost it. He should have passed command on when he got greviously sick. He should have prevented Pickett’s charge. When the Union controlled the key terrain he needed a plan to deal with it or leave.

    Best – Thomas Jackson in the Shenendoah Valley. To this day officers can glean lessons and insight from Jackson’s command. His use of mobility, intelligence, deception and cunning let him outwit, out maneuver and out fight his superior opponent.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at

%d bloggers like this: